As South Africa's residential property market continues its upward trajectory, buy-to-let investments are increasingly attractive. However, the success of these investments hinges on securing reliable tenants, as a bad tenant can undermine even the most promising investment. A lack of thorough tenant vetting can result in costly consequences, such as unpaid rent, property damage and even a lengthy eviction processes. For private landlords and rental agents alike, proper tenant screening and vetting are critical to protecting investments and ensuring a smooth landlord-tenant relationship. Here's how to identify red flags and implement robust screening processes to pre-empt risks.
The High Cost of a Bad Tenant
A non-performing tenant can place significant financial and emotional burdens on landlords. The impact extends beyond missed rental payments, often extending to unpaid utility bills, neglected maintenance, and property damage, which further escalates costs. In South Africa, the process of evicting a defaulting tenant is legally complex, costly, and time-consuming. Evictions must comply with the formal procedures outlined in the Prevention of Illegal Eviction from and Unlawful Occupation of Land Act (PIE Act), and can take anywhere between four to eighteen months. To further complicate matters, landlords must usually pursue a separate legal action to recover outstanding arrears and payment of damages, which entails additional legal fees, court appearances, and administrative effort. These challenges emphasise the importance of initial tenant screening and vetting to mitigate the risks associated with defaulting tenants.
Identifying Red Flags in Prospective Tenants
Spotting warning signs early can save landlords from long-term headaches. Red flags fall into two categories: obvious and subtle.
Obvious Red Flags
-
Poor Credit Score: A poor credit score signals financial mismanagement. With South Africa's high debt levels, a thorough credit check is non-negotiable. It reveals a tenant's ability to meet financial obligations, including rent.
-
Affordability Issues: Monthly rent should not exceed 30% of a tenant's gross monthly income. Landlords must verify income through payslips and bank statements to ensure tenants can cover rent, utilities, and other expenses.
-
Lack of References: Reliable tenants provide references from previous landlords. If a tenant has no rental history, a co-signer or employer reference is essential. Vague or unverifiable references are a cause for concern.
Subtle Red Flags
-
Inconsistent Employment History: Frequent job changes or unverifiable employment suggest instability, which may translate to unreliable rent payments.
-
Criminal Background: A criminal background check, offered by services like TPN, ensures tenants are safe and trustworthy.
-
Behavioural Cues: Tenants who are difficult to reach, overly demanding, or aggressive during initial interactions may indicate future disputes. Trust your instincts if something feels off.
-
Reluctance to Follow Process: Tenants who push to skip credit checks, offer their own reports, or haggle excessively over rent or deposits may be hiding financial or personal issues.
-
Lifestyle Concerns: Signs like arriving drunk at viewings, vague answers about who will live in the property, or resistance to house rules (like a no-pet policy) can hint at potential problems like subletting or disregard for lease terms.
One's sober intuition is rarely wrong. It is thus vital to combine gut instinct with proper screening.
Practical Steps to Mitigate Risks
To avoid bad tenants, landlords and agents should adopt a systematic vetting process:
-
Run Comprehensive Credit Checks: Use a registered credit bureau to verify a tenant's financial history, including debt repayments, judgments, and credit accounts.
-
Verify Income and Employment: Request three to six months of bank statements and payslips, and confirm employment directly with the employer. This ensures the tenant's income supports the 30% rent-to-income rule.
-
Check References Thoroughly: Contact previous landlords to confirm the tenant's payment history and behaviour. If no rental history exists, employer references or a co-signer can provide assurance.
-
Conduct Criminal Background Checks: Use services like TPN to perform SAPS checks, ensuring the tenant poses no safety risks.
-
Require a Deposit: The Rental Housing Act permits landlords to collect a deposit (typically one-and-a-half to two months' rent) to cover potential damages or unpaid rent. Tenants who resist paying upfront may struggle with future payments.
-
Draft a Watertight Lease: Include clear terms, such as a cancellation clause, to protect against early lease terminations. The CPA allows tenants to cancel with 20 business days' notice, but landlords can recover reasonable costs like advertising or agent fees.
-
Perform Inspections: Conduct detailed incoming and outgoing inspections with date-stamped photos, signed by both parties, to document the property's condition. Regular interim inspections (every three months) help identify issues early.
-
Communicate Clearly: Maintain open, written communication with tenants. If issues arise, remain calm and seek advice from agents or attorneys to resolve disputes professionally.
How Technology Simplifies Tenant Vetting
Modern tools streamline the screening process, making it easier to identify reliable tenants. Platforms like TenantHive offer automated vetting solutions that integrate credit checks, tenant behavior insights, and rental history analysis. By leveraging national credit bureau data and advanced analytics, TenantHive provides landlords with a comprehensive view of a tenant's financial reliability and past rental performance. This reduces the risk of missed red flags and saves time for busy landlords and agents. For those managing multiple properties, such automation ensures consistency and efficiency, allowing you to focus on maintaining your investment.
Conclusion
In South Africa's competitive rental market, the temptation to fill vacancies quickly can lead to costly mistakes. Bad tenants can drain resources through unpaid rent, property damage, or legal battles. By implementing thorough screening processes—credit checks, income verification, reference checks, and criminal background checks—landlords can minimize risks and secure reliable tenants. Tools like TenantHive enhance this process with automated, data-driven insights, offering peace of mind and protecting your investment. Landlords drastically minimizes their risk through upfront tenant screening. Take the time to vet tenants properly, and your property investment will thrive.